U doktorskom radu polazi se od činjenice da je održivost turizma temeljna koncepcija turističkog razvoja, što potvrđuju mnogobrojne studije kojima se nastoji doprinijeti poboljšanju održivosti turizma u različitim područjima i kontekstima. Budući da su zaštićena područja primarno zadužena za zaštitu izrazito osjetljivih i ugroženih resursa te vrijednosti samog područja, razvoj turizma u takvim područjima predstavlja trajni izazov unutar kojeg se trebaju kontinuirano optimizirati odnosi između zaštite i održivog korištenja resursa s ciljem održavanja ravnoteže između koristi i troškova, odnosno pritisaka. Stoga, usprkos brojnim istraživanjima u području održivog turizma, studije koje imaju za cilj novim spoznajama doprinijeti poboljšanju održivosti turizma u zaštićenim područjima su opravdane, posebno unutar kategorija koje su nedovoljno istražene.
S obzirom na istaknutu problematiku, doktorski rad je usmjeren na utvrđivanje pretpostavljenog doprinosa posjetitelja poboljšanju održivosti turizma parkova prirode u skladu s definiranim predmetnom istraživanja. Glavni cilj je uspostaviti te ispitati valjanost i pouzdanost konceptualnog modela za mjerenje utjecaja pozitivne percepcije posjetitelja o važnosti održivog korištenja resursa u turizmu parkova prirode na njihovo zadovoljstvo turističkim resursima, spremnost plaćanja za poboljšanje doživljaja i spremnost plaćanja za jačanje održivosti turizma parkova prirode.
Pored teorijskog pregleda problematike i glavnih konstrukata konceptualnog modela, provedeno je empirijsko istraživanje sukladno postavljenom cilju i formuliranim hipotezama. Prikupljanje primarnih podataka provedeno je metodom anketiranja (online i onsite – na svim lokalitetima odabranih parkova prirode), korištenjem strukturiranog anketnog upitnika u okviru kojeg su čestice glavnih konstrukata mjerene Likertovom mjernom ljestvicom sa sedam stupnja intenziteta za potrebe testiranja formuliranih hipoteza. Prikupljanje i statistička obrada podataka provedena je na jednostavnom slučajnom uzorku kojeg čine 690 ispitanika između posjetitelja jednog od tri predmetna parka prirode (PP Lonjsko polje, PP Papuk, PP Žumberak – Samoborsko gorje). Testiranje formuliranih hipoteza provedeno je primjenom metode modeliranja strukturnih jednadžbi primjenom tehnike djelomičnih najmanjih kvadrata (PLS-SEM) i Kruskal-Wallis testa.
Temeljem provedenih analiza i dobivenih rezultata empirijskog istraživanja, potvrđeno je pet od ukupno sedam hipoteza koje su testirane primjenom metode PLS-SEM, dok je primjenom Kruskal-Wallis testa potvrđena jedna od ukupno dvije hipoteze. Metodom PLS-SEM potvrđena je pretpostavka multidimenzionalnosti konstrukta spremnost plaćanja veće cijene posjetitelja za jačanje održivosti turizma parkova prirode, kao i pozitivan, statistički značajan utjecaj pozitivne percepcije posjetitelja o važnosti održivog korištenja resursa u turizmu parkova prirode na njihovo zadovoljstvo turističkim resursima te na spremnost plaćanja veće cijene za jačanje održivosti turizma parkova prirode. Također je potvrđen pozitivan, statistički značajan utjecaj zadovoljstva posjetitelja turističkim resursima parkova prirode na njihovu spremnost plaćanja veće cijene za poboljšanje turističkog doživljaja te utjecaj spremnosti plaćanja veće cijene posjetitelja za poboljšanje turističkog doživljaja na njihovu spremnost plaćanja veće cijene za jačanje održivosti turizma parkova prirode. Primjenom Kruskal-Wallis testa, potvrđeno je postojanje statistički značajne razlike u spremnosti plaćanja veće cijene posjetitelja između dimenzija održivosti turizma parkova prirode s obzirom na njihovu pozitivnu percepciju o važnosti održivog korištenja resursa u turizmu parkova prirode.
Doktorskim radom ostvaren je znanstveni doprinos na konceptualnoj, empirijsko-metodološkoj i aplikativnoj razini. U kontekstu konceptualnog doprinosa, sustavno su prikazane posebnosti i dosadašnja istraživanja predmetnih konstrukata konceptualnog modela, kao i područje održivog turizma, turizma u zaštićenim područjima te konverzije i održivog korištenja resursa u turizmu. Empirijsko-metodološki doprinos očituje se u dizajnu i prilagodbi instrumenta za mjerenje, ocjenjivanju konstrukata te prikazu izravnih, neizravnih i ukupnih utjecaja između konstrukata konceptualnog modela primjenom odgovarajuće metode multivarijatne statističke analize.
Doktorski rad doprinosi boljem razumijevanju potencijalnih pozitivnih utjecaja posjetitelja na održivost turizma parkova prirode na temelju percepcije o važnosti održivog korištenja resursa i zadovoljstva turističkim resursima, kao i na temelju spremnosti plaćanja veće cijene za poboljšanje doživljaja i jačanje održivosti turizma parkova prirode mjerenim na osnovi održivog korištenja i upravljanja resursima u parkovima prirode. Također, na aplikativnoj razini dane su smjernice za jačanje održivosti turizma u parkovima prirode optimalnim korištenjem i umrežavanjem različitih resursa na području parkova prirode, kao i preporuke za buduća istraživanja u turizmu zaštićenih područja, a posebno u turizmu parkovima prirode. Zaključuje se da su postignuti zadani ciljevi doktorskog rada, pri čemu je ujedno stvorena i osnova za buduća istraživanja u smjeru poboljšanja održivosti turizma u destinacijama s drugačijim ili sličnim obilježjima.
|Sažetak (engleski)|| |
Sustainable tourism can be seen as an approach that can provide solutions to the key challenges of tourism (ecological, social, and economic), all with the aim of ensuring permanent benefits to all parties involved, from the local community, region and environment in which tourism takes place, to quality assurance products, extraordinary experience, and visitor satisfaction. Therefore, for the destination to improve the tourism sustainability, it is necessary to optimally use and manage resources and stakeholders in the destination by applying appropriate strategies and tools with the aim of balancing expected benefits and unwanted costs. In this context, it is assumed that sustainable tourism should deliver the expected benefits to all parties, which can be observed at the level of:
• visitors (awesome tourist experience and satisfaction, environmental and social contribution from travel, etc.),
• protected areas (social and political support for protected areas, improvement of protection, tourism, and other infrastructure through revenue from visits, as well as optimal engagement, and management of all resources, especially when the number of visitors increases, etc.) and
• local communities and wider area (inclusion of the local population in the provision of various services and products in tourism independently or in combination with those of protected areas, increasing employability and better paid jobs, improvement of life quality, etc.).
The resources of protected areas can be viewed as all attributes, goods, values, or phenomena that can be the subject of tourist use, and for which visitors visit the destination, such as various attractions, amenities, landscapes, events, facilities, or a combination of several of them as part of products or services. Although each resource independently or as part of a product has its own value, all resources are interconnected and contribute to the tourist experience and visitor satisfaction. This means that although most visitors primarily visit the destination for an individual attraction (e.g., wonderful waterfalls), they certainly use several different resources of the protected area on which the tourist experience is based (local transport and guides, tourism and other infrastructure, additional facilities, etc.).
It is important to point out that the approach to resource use and management affects not only visitors, but also residents and resources as well. It is assumed that the optimal use, sustainable management, and inclusion of all resources in nature park tourism would have a positive impact on visitor satisfaction, especially among visitors with a positive perception towards sustainable tourism, and which are assumed to be willing to contribute financially to the improvement of the tourism experience and sustainability of nature parks in which resources are sustainably used and managed.
A lack of previous studies examining visitors as important stakeholders in sustainable tourism have been identified in literature (Kastenholz et al., 2018; López-Sánchez & Pulido Fernández, 2016; Shamsub & Lebel, 2012; Moeller et al., 2011; Nicholas & Thapa, 2010; Nepal, 2008; Dolnicar et al., 2008). In particular, there is a lack of studies on visitors' perception of the sustainable resources use importance in tourism (Araújo et al., 2022; Nejati et al., 2015), on which support for sustainable tourism may depend (Kastenholz et al., 2018), and for which also assumes that it is related to an increased level of visitor satisfaction in a protected area (de Oliveira et al., 2020) and where visitor satisfaction can influence their willingness to pay a higher price for sustainable products and the sustainability of the destination (Bigné et al., 2008).
A detailed literature review showed that no studies simultaneously examine the relationships between the previously highlighted concepts in the case of tourism in protected areas from the visitor’s perspective, especially at the level of nature parks, which have been neglected in research in relation to national parks. Therefore, it is considered justified to problematize the sustainability of nature park tourism in the context of optimal use and sustainable management and involvement of various resources from the visitor’s perspective, both in the context of satisfaction and in the context of behavioural intentions such as willingness to pay to improve the experience and sustainability of nature park tourism.
Regarding the highlighted problem, which was preceded by a detailed theory review and previous research, the subject of the doctoral thesis is to examine and determine the impact of visitors' perception of the importance of sustainable resources use in tourism on their satisfaction with tourism resources and, consequently, on the willingness to pay a higher price for improving the experience and for the sustainability of tourism in nature parks. According to the subject, the main goal of the doctoral thesis is to establish and to examine the validity and reliability of conceptual model for measuring the influence of visitors' positive perception of the importance of sustainable resources use in nature park tourism on their satisfaction with tourism resources, willingness to pay for improving the experience and willingness to pay for the sustainability strengthening of nature park tourism.
In addition to the theoretical review of the problem and the main constructs of the conceptual model, empirical research was conducted in accordance with the set main and auxiliary goals and the formulated hypotheses, within which primary data were collected using the survey method. The survey was conducted using a structured questionnaire that was created in two forms (electronic and paper format) in Croatian and English, while data collection was carried out online and onsite – at all localities of the selected nature parks. To test the hypotheses, a questionnaire was created according to the previous scientific literature in which the variables of the main constructs were measured using a seven-point Likert scale.
The target group of the empirical research were visitors who visited one of the three selected nature parks in Croatia in the last 12 months, which differ from each other regarding additional international designations (Lonjsko Polje Nature Park, Papuk Nature Park and Žumberak – Samoborsko gorje Nature Park). Given that the research includes visitors who visited nature parks in 2021 (for which the number of visits is known) and in 2022, for which the number of visits is unknown, the population can be viewed as infinite and in this case simple random sampling is used, in accordance with the defined approach of Kothari (2004). Ultimately, data analysis was performed on a sample of 690 respondents.
Univariate and multivariate statistical analysis methods were used in the process of analysing the collected data. Univariate, i.e., descriptive statistical analysis was used to calculate absolute and relative frequencies for sociodemographic characteristics of respondents and characteristics of visits to nature parks, while average values and deviations from average values were calculated for all variables of the main latent constructs. In the research, men predominate (62.90%), and the most represented age group of respondents is 35 to 50 years old (40.15%), while the dominant level of education of the respondents is bachelor's and master's degree (58.70%). Domestic visitors dominate (96.81%), and most respondents come from a smaller town (43.77%), as well as the most represented group is the group with a monthly household income between 1 000 and 2 000 euros (50.29%).
The most common reason for visiting the nature park is enjoying nature and landscape (54.35%), and most visitors primarily (directly) come to the nature park (77%) and mostly organize their visit independently (80.58%), during the weekend (81, 62%), accompanied by friends and/or colleagues (44.64%). Most of them had previously visited the nature park in the range of four to five visits (44.64%), where one-day visits dominate (81.16%). As for the respondents who spent the night (n = 205), most of them spent the night in the nature park area accommodation (63.41%), mostly in private accommodation (40.49%), most often up to three nights. Ultimately, most of the respondents spend up to 50 euros per day (78.7%).
Descriptive statistical analysis of the main constructs identified the lowest average score for the latent construct visitors’ willingness to pay a higher price to improve the experience in nature parks (𝑥̅ = 4.38), and the highest for the latent construct visitor’s perception of the importance of sustainable resources use in nature park tourism (𝑥̅ = 5.82). Since an ordinal scale (Likert) was used to measure the main research constructs, non-parametric methods of multivariate statistical analysis were used. First, the method of partial least squares structural equation modelling (PLS-SEM) was applied to test hypotheses related to determining the significance of defined influences between latent constructs in the conceptual model, and the Kruskal-Wallis test was used to test hypotheses related to the examination of significant differences between variables. MS Office Excel, Statistica 13.3 software package and the SmartPLS 4.0.9 program were used for the statistical analysis of the collected data.
Based on the conducted analysis and the results of the empirical research, five of the seven tested hypotheses were confirmed using the PLS-SEM method, while one of the two hypotheses was confirmed using the Kruskal-Wallis test. Using the PLS-SEM method, the assumption of the multidimensionality of the construct visitors’ willingness to pay a higher price for the sustainability strengthening of nature park tourism (H1) was confirmed, as well as the positive, statistically significant influence of visitors' positive perception of the importance of sustainable resources use in nature park tourism on their satisfaction with tourist resources of nature parks (H2- 1, β = 0.525; p = 0.000) and willingness to pay a higher price for the sustainability strengthening of nature park tourism (H2-3, β = 0.285; p = 0.000). Equally, the positive, statistically significant influence of visitors' satisfaction with the tourist resources of nature parks on their willingness to pay a higher price to improve the experience in nature parks was confirmed (H3-1, β = 0.304; p = 0.000), as well as the influence of visitors' willingness to pay a higher price to improve experience in nature parks on their willingness to pay a higher price for the sustainability strengthening of nature park tourism (H4, β = 0.462; p = 0.000).
Applying the Kruskal-Wallis test, the existence of a statistically significant difference in the visitors’ willingness to pay a higher price between the dimensions of the sustainability of nature park tourism was confirmed, given their positive perception of the importance of sustainable resources use in nature park tourism (H5-1). The remaining hypotheses were rejected because no direct connection was established between the observed constructs (positive and statistically significant influence) in the model (H2-2 and H3-2) and there is no statistically significant difference between the observed variables (H5-2).
The doctoral thesis achieved the scientific contribution at the conceptual, empirical-methodological and application level. In the context of the conceptual contribution, the peculiarities and previous research of the considered constructs of the conceptual model, as well as the area of sustainable tourism, tourism in protected areas, and the transformation and sustainable use of resources, are systematically presented. The empirical-methodological contribution is manifested in the design and adaptation of the instrument for measurement, evaluation, and presentation of direct and indirect influences between the constructs of the conceptual model using the method of multivariate statistical analysis. The doctoral thesis contributes to a better understanding of the potential positive effects of visitors on the sustainability of nature park tourism based on the perception of the importance of sustainable resources use, satisfaction with tourist resources, as well as the visitors’ willingness to pay a higher price to improve the experience and for the sustainability strengthening of nature park tourism based on sustainable use and management of resources in nature parks. Additionally, guidelines are given for the sustainability strengthening of tourism in nature parks by optimal use and networking of various resources in and around nature parks, as well as recommendations for future research in protected area tourism, especially in nature park tourism. It is concluded that the set goals of the doctoral thesis have been achieved, while at the same time, the basis for future research in the direction of the sustainability strengthening of tourism in destinations with different or similar characteristics has been created.